« Things worth reading: 25th July 2012 | Main | Things worth reading: 26th July 2012 »

July 25, 2012

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a01053620481c970b016768bb9668970b

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Forget about rebuilding trust ... it won't wash:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Zerocredit_UK

Excellent post, Chris. Trust is earned and the honesty which earns it starts with such as my mother's recommendation to "expect nothing and you will not be disappointed".

The industry needs to appreciate its management of our money underpins every single aspect of our lives - it is hard earned cash to fend for our families and our very modest future that they're handling.

When so many of us know pensioners under-heating their homes, working families going hungry, family businesses going under and youngsters struggling to find work, it's small wonder big bonuses seem unfair.

To then learn of the calculations and connivance, the communication of platitudes as corruption begins to emerge (the BBA to BoE emails about LIBOR are so telling) creates revulsion.

We saw kids locked away with alacrity for far lesser crimes last summer, so where is our justice, now? There is nothing to rebuild when the glass houses that were built were rotten. Casino banking has been an abusive affair to which its victims will not return.

Humility is in order.
(Emma)

Paul Peters

Good post.
The idea is that "rebuilding trust" can be done via impression management, advertisement, astroturf, marketing and spin.... and this is exactly how one looses trust.
Maybe start by public excecution of marketeers.

James Marcus Gosdin

Chris, your points are exceptionally well presented. There is one factor that may be important to a clearer understanding of this issue, and that is the question of whether clients ever TRULY trusted banks in the first place!

As a customer, if you were with an institution and you made money, then your feeling about them was much 'warmer' than it would have been had they been losing your money, but as far as actually TRUSTING them, perhaps that over-extends the limit of the term. Gordon Gecko was not totally correct, but if you join with greedy thieves, you DO expect to have a pay day, and for many of the individuals AND institutions, there was no concern for the customer's return. If you are at a table in Las Vegas, and you are WINNING, do you feel trust toward your dealer? That person may be the method by which you are allowed to show a gain, but their ultimate goal is to beat you. ONLY if the dealer takes his cards face-up do you have the benefit of transparency.

There IS no trust to rebuild, only NEW trust to be EARNED. This time around, the industry has a new chance to win that trust, as you have said, with transparency. If the situation we face now happens again, there will, very likely, not be another opportunity for redemption.

Kevin

Chris,
I think that the issue of trust in banking is a great deal more fundamental than the conclusion to your article suggests.

Perhaps the end of the Mayan calendar does not herald some physical change but rather a shift in consciousness. With greater numbers of people questioning many of the accepted foundations of our modern civilization such as the global banking system.
Many believe that it is not just a few bad apples, as the mainstream media tend to portray, but rather a global financial system that is rotten at its core.
1. They question how the hundreds of billions of dollars related to drug trafficking move around the planet so easily? They see Wachovia being identified as having laundered USD 378 Billion for Mexican drug cartels with nobody going to prison and a paltry fine of USD 160 million.
2. They wonder why the global banks donate so much to the campaigns of politicians of all stripes. They ask ‘contributions or bribes’?
3. They ponder at the revolving door policy between employees of Regulators and the organizations they supposedly police.
4. Frequently now they understand that central banks such as the Federal reserve “are no more Federal than Federal Express” with private shareholders, issuing money as debt.
5. They question the very concept of fractional reserve banking with an elastic fiat money supply that leads to inflation and bubbles that erode their hard earned wealth.
6. They struggle to understand the value to society of high frequency trading.
7. What are derivatives they ask, why do we need them and how can that market be valued at USD 1,200,000,000,000,000 (USD 200k for every person on the planet)
8. Why do the banks get to keep such huge profits they ask, whilst their losses are socialized, paid for by their children and their grandchildren in turn?
9. They try to understand why a petty thief goes to jail so easily and yet many in the financial industry seem to be able to commit crimes with impunity
10. What does KYC stand for, is it ‘Know Your Customer’? In the case of money laundering they reason that it could stand for ‘Know Your Competition’. Or perhaps with the invasiveness of the current system it could be thought of as ‘Kontrol Your Customer’.

As you note it is perhaps true that most of the people working in the banking system are ‘honest’ and simply trying to do the best they can. However the ‘dishonest few’ that you refer to are concentrated at the power centers of both their organizations and the financial system. Therefore many believe that it is not simply a questions of modifying the structure or introducing new rules.
There are growing calls to tear down the structurally unsound edifice and start again with new foundations, with perhaps a limit on the size of the building to prevent the creation of global ‘too big to fail’ institutions.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Twitter FSClub

    follow me on Twitter

    Your email address:


    Powered by FeedBlitz

    Search blog


    Amazon Digital Bank

    Financial Brand Editor's Choice

    Alex: The Finanser BlogAlex at the Financial Services Club
    Gaping Void: The Finanser BlogGaping Void's Hugh MacLeod worked with the Finanser
    Wordle: The Finanser Blog

    The Financial Brand

    NetBanker

    Payments News - from Glenbrook Partners

    Payments RSS

    Tomorrow's Transactions blog

    Analytics